Group exercise practice

The charity committee: five moments in a 30-minute discussion. Choose the most useful thing to do at each.

Your group of five is the committee of a student charity. You have £5,000 to spend on one fundraising project next term, and 30 minutes to agree one recommendation.

The assessors watch how each person works with the group, not only the final choice.

The four options
ProjectCostExpected raisedVolunteers needed
Charity ball£3,500£9,00020
Sponsored run£800£4,5008
Online auction£300£2,5003
Three quiz nights£900£3,6006

Suggested time 30 minutes · 0 min so far

  1. Moment 1

    Five minutes in, two people are arguing loudly for the ball. Nobody has looked at the costs yet.

    What is the most useful thing to do?

  2. Moment 2

    Someone says the sponsored run would raise the most money.

    What is the most useful thing to do?

  3. Moment 3

    One member has not spoken for ten minutes.

    What is the most useful thing to do?

  4. Moment 4

    With eight minutes left, the group is still debating whether to do two projects.

    What is the most useful thing to do?

  5. Moment 5

    The group chooses the ball. You think finding 20 volunteers is a real risk.

    What is the most useful thing to do?

How to do well in a group exercise

  • Read the brief for the goal and the time limit, and keep both in view.
  • Make points with reasons and figures from the pack, not just opinions.
  • Build on others' ideas by name, and bring in anyone who has gone quiet.
  • Summarise where the group agrees, and propose how to settle the rest.
  • Disagree politely, once, with a reason. Then help the group finish.

Clifford Chance, for one, lists a group exercise on its assessment day. See each employer's published process.

Questions people ask

What do assessors look for in a group exercise?

How you work with others to reach the task's goal: contributing ideas with reasons, listening and building on others, bringing quieter people in, and keeping the group to the brief and the time.

Should I take the lead?

Only if it helps the group. Keeping time, summarising and bringing in others are leadership too. Talking most is not the same as contributing most.

What if the group makes a decision I disagree with?

Say why once, clearly, with your reason. If the group still disagrees, support the decision and help make it work.

Keep this practice to hand.

We email you this page and new free interview and assessment centre practice.