Skip to content
Year 2Pure, second pass

Contradiction and first-principles proof clinic

A ready lesson: 14 slides, a 8-question worksheet (40 marks) and every answer worked.

Slides

PowerPoint, fully editable

Worksheet

Warm up 2 · Core 4 · Stretch 2

Warm up

Start here. Everyone should finish these.

1Routine, level 2 · Calculator · 5 marks

You may use the fact that if the prime 3 divides a2a^2, it divides the integer a.

(a)Prove by contradiction that 3\sqrt{3} is irrational.[4]
(b)Deduce that 3+33+\sqrt{3} is irrational.[1]
2Routine, level 2 · Calculator · 5 marks

You may use the fact that if the prime 5 divides a2a^2, it divides the integer a.

(a)Prove by contradiction that 5\sqrt{5} is irrational.[4]
(b)Deduce that 4+54+\sqrt{5} is irrational.[1]

And 6 more questions in the pack.

Answers

Worked steps and marks
Question 1
(a)An assumed reduced fraction would have numerator and denominator both divisible by 3.
  1. Assume a reduced positive-integer fraction for the square root.
    3=a/b  ⟹  a2=3b2\sqrt{3}=a/b\implies a^2=3b^2
  2. The prime divides a, so put a=pc for this prime.
  3. Substitute to show the prime also divides the denominator.
    b2=3c2b^2=3c^2
  4. Both have a common prime divisor, contradicting the reduced fraction assumption. Result: An assumed reduced fraction would have numerator and denominator both divisible by 3.
  • M1Assume a reduced positive-integer fraction for the square root.
  • A1The prime divides a, so put a=pc for this prime.
  • M1Substitute to show the prime also divides the denominator.
  • A1Both have a common prime divisor, contradicting the reduced fraction assumption.
(b)If the sum were rational, subtracting the integer would make the square root rational.
  1. Rational numbers remain rational after subtracting an integer. Result: If the sum were rational, subtracting the integer would make the square root rational.
  • B1Rational numbers remain rational after subtracting an integer.

More Pure, second pass packs

Every topic

Matches Pearson Edexcel 9MA0. The core content is the same on every board. Independent resources. Not endorsed by Pearson.