Writing the HSC Legal Studies Section III option responses
Section III has a question on every option, each with two alternatives. You answer two alternatives, each on a different option: 25 marks each, about 1000 words each, half the paper.
Marks
50: two responses, 25 each
Length
About 1000 words each
Choice
One alternative on each of your two options
Key words
Evaluate, assess, discuss, examine
A plan for 25 marks
In reading time, choose the alternative where you can name the most law and reach a clear judgement.
An introduction that defines the key terms and gives your judgement on effectiveness in one sentence.
Three or four body paragraphs, each on one issue or response, with the law you studied as evidence, its strengths and its limits, and a link back to the question.
Effectiveness is the question
Most option questions ask, in some form, how well the law achieves justice. Weigh legal and non-legal responses, say what has changed through law reform, and finish with a judgement you can defend from the evidence you used.
Try 2 questions
Question 1
In a hypothetical case, the ice dispenser on Mei's new fridge stops working after three weeks, though the fridge still cools normally. One cheap part has failed and can be replaced in a day. Under the Australian Consumer Law, what can Mei do first?
Question 2
What is the only ground for a divorce order under the Family Law Act 1975?