Law School Test

If, only if and unless

Many Logical Reasoning questions turn on rules. Translate each rule into an arrow, chain the arrows, and use only the contrapositive to go backward.

If A, then BA → B
A only if BA → B
Not A unless BA → B
Every A is BA → B
No A is BA → not B

The one valid way back

From A → B you may conclude not B → not A, the contrapositive. Nothing else runs backward.

Two classic errors

  • Taking B as proof of A: 'If it rains, the match is off. The match is off, so it rained.'
  • Taking not A as proof of not B: 'If it rains, the match is off. It did not rain, so the match is on.'

Try 3 questions

Question 1

If the museum receives the grant, it will extend its weekend hours. The museum will extend its weekend hours only if it hires more guards. The museum will never hire more guards.

If the statements above are true, which one of the following must also be true?

Question 2

Unless the river is below flood level, the ferry will not run. The river is below flood level only if there has been no heavy rain this week.

If the statements above are true and the ferry is running, which one of the following must be true?

Question 3

Every painting hanging in the north gallery belongs to the museum's collection and was painted before 1900. Every painting in the museum's collection that was painted before 1900 has been cleaned in the past ten years.

Next step

Questions people ask

Why does 'only if' point the other way from 'if'?

'A only if B' says B is required for A. So whenever A happens, B has happened: A → B.

How does 'unless' work?

'Not A unless B' means A requires B, so A → B. Read 'unless' as 'if not'.

LSAT® is a trademark registered by LSAC, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this site.